Making ICT a part of a school’s vision

An ICT future in our school
An ICT future in our school

The primary school where my children are enrolled have taken steps towards preparing the school for the introduction of information and communication technology (ICT). The governing body are thinking of equipping teachers with laptops and Gauteng Education department have equipped the school with a set of tablets. These are exciting moves for our school and leadership are to be commended for their bold steps.
Now, I don’t want to be a wet blanket – but I’d like to suggest a little caution to parents and management before the school goes ahead and invests too much money in ICT’s. Before budgets are blown on laptops, tablets, data projectors, software etc. it is important that the school look at the following:

  1. Manage expectations of staff, students and parent
  2. Find an educator who’ll act as a champion, not a technician
  3. Install suitable infrastructure that will support the vision for the incorporation.

Manage expectations
Computers and education are presented by many people as a given. Silicon Valley believes that they have a new technological solution for teachers that will help them solve all their problems – from admin to assessment. The business community, concerned that schools are still stuck in an industrial mind-set, want empowered employees, comfortable with working on tools of the 21st century. Parents like schools equipped with new technologies because they demonstrate that the school cares about children future.
Rapid adoption of computers, laptops, cell phones and tablets across society have left an impression that technology is driving change in education and schools have to adopt technology or they will be left behind. Yes, here’s no doubt that ICT can play in education. In the classroom, for example, ICT can take on a range of roles – library, noticeboard, intercom, jotter, simulator etc.. There’s also no doubt that ICT makes it possible to participate in learning environments that transcend classroom walls. Where we all get a bit lost, is when we focus on “what the device can do”. Instead, a school that is thinking of incorporating computers into premises should be asking is – “what aspect of ICT will best contribute to improved learning?”
Introducing ICT into a school requires more than equipping teachers and students with devices, infrastructure and the internet. If a school is not clear about what they want students to accomplish with these devices, if students and teachers are not ready for these activities and if there is no groundswell of support amongst parents, staff and students for using these devices in the manner envisioned, then it is likely that in the medium to the long term, this initiative will be costly and underused.

Find a champion
It’s assumed that computers and education are inseparable and much marketing makes the point that technology alone can deliver desired benefits to education. Technology does not make – except by lucky accident – a good teacher. It simply magnifies practice. If technology is well used, then it’s effects are noticeable. However, Ill-considered use of the technology may have results which are the opposite of what was originally planned. So before we start talking about equipping a school with tablets or laptops should be clear about how teachers are intended to use the devices. I’d suggest that the school finds a champion that that communicates the overall set of goals of the project, the components that will be required for success and the schedule for rolling out the stages of digital learning. Such a champion should be able to address the following questions

What do you want teachers to accomplish with their own computing device?

  1. Distributing content
  2. Collaboration
  3. Communication
  4. Assessment
  5. Admin

What digital content will teachers be expected to use with their own computing device?

  1. Content supplied by the department
  2. Content that has been purchased from a commercial publisher
  3. Content that they have authored themselves
  4. Content that is licensed as an Open Educational resource

How do you envisage teachers using the device?

  1. Distributing learning materials
  2. Distributing admin information
  3. Projecting Interactive learning materials
  4. Delivering multimedia

How are teachers going to collaborate with their devices

  1. What are teachers going to use to connect to each other (email, instant messaging, social media and intranet)
  2. Is the school’s infrastructure sufficiently prepared for network and wireless access?
  3. Is the school going to pay for Internet access
  4. Who is going to be responsible for managing the various services
  5. Who will be responsible for technical support

An enabling infrastructure
School buildings need an infrastructure that can support an influx of devices accessing the network. With both tablets and laptops it is important that as many wireless access points as possible—at least one per room. If the school’s programme take off then children will be bringing their devices (cell phone in their pocket and an iPad, tablet, or eReader) and it may be good to plan on two devices per student.
Tablets are portable – their lightness makes them easy to carry around the school. The inbuilt multimedia capacity within tablets make it easier to record sound, capture and record video and record Tablets have access to a range of educational apps and for special education, apps on tablets are more suitable to support students with speech, communication, wring and reading issues. When it comes to functionality – laptops have more processing power than tablets and can be used to support larger programmes and projects. Laptops also have more memory than tablets. Research on laptops is preferred by students because it’s easier to swap between various sources. Data entry remains easier on laptops as full keyboards are ideal for entering, capturing and working with data

Draw on the many sources of experience and expertise
The school can and should take advantage of the many resources out there to assist schools with preparing themselves for getting the school ICT ready. The Laptop for Teachers project is a government sponsored project intended to provide educators with Laptops. Microsoft’s Partners in Learning programme, has a great set of resources to assist teachers get on top of technology. Their School Technology Innovation Centre (STIC), located at SciBono is a wonderful resource for infrastructure. While I have not yet met the folk from Tablet Academy, I have been impressed with their advice on Twitter. They offer a free consultancy service. Last but not least, don’t forget SchoolNet . With over 20 years’ experience in schools, they are an invaluable resource.

Conclusion
Computers place in education is presented by many people as a given. The messages from Silicon Valley is around technological solutions for teachers. Hardware, software, apps, devices etc promise to help them solve  challenges  – from admin to assessment. The business community, concerned that schools are still stuck in an industrial mind-set, want empowered employees, comfortable with working on tools of the 21st century. Parents like schools equipped with new technologies because they demonstrate that the school cares about children future.

Students behind screens or teachers projecting a multimedia presentation do not necessarily mean that learning is taking place. Computers might enable good teaching, but incorrectly used, their capacity to distract is great. If the schools goals are clear, an educator, and not a technician is leading the project and the leadership of the school can see how ICT infrastructure could be another building block in accomplishing those goals, then the school may see results from their spending on ICT.

 

Digital Divides & Participation Gaps

digital literacies
digital literacies

Wits has made it explicit in its vision 2022 that it would like to known as a “tech savvy” intuition. On our digitally equipped connected campus, academics and students do make regular and expert use of digital technologies to meet their communication, scholarship and teaching needs. Ability of staff to access and use the network satisfactorily is a given. Students skills with finding, evaluating, utilising, creating, manipulating and transforming digital material on the internet, within a virtual learning environment, on software packages, in digital textbooks, working on exercise software, listening to podcasts, participating in simulations or playing learning games etc. is generally assumed or remedied with a brief training session. However, for many students, especially from disadvantaged backgrounds, such digital fluencies are not automatic. A range of digital divides or ‘inequality of access to the Internet’ have limited these students opportunity to access and use ICTs’.

Within South Africa’s secondary education system, more traditional forms of literacy have been developed and while post matric students should be able to read for knowledge, write coherently, and think critically about the written word as undergraduate students, they have not necessarily been exposed to technology enhanced learning. For Wits “tech savvy vision” to be realised, the institution will have to take specific steps that will actively address the various barriers to access. Van Dijk and Hacker (2003) argue that there are four types of barriers to access:

  • The lack of ‘‘material access’’ means a lack of possession of computers and network connections.
  • The lack of ‘‘mental access’’ refers to a lack of elementary digital experience.
  • The lack of ‘‘skill access’’ is a lack of digital skills.
  • The lack of ‘‘usage access’’ signifies the lack of meaningful usage opportunities.

At present Wits runs specific projects to address material access issues. If Wits is to address the other three digital divides and assist its students to gain digital experience, practice digital skills and learn appropriate and responsible behaviours within a meaningful context, then as an institution, Wits will have to go beyond simply creating conditions for material access and systematically and deliberately prepare students so that they can indeed learn anything, anytime, anywhere.
eLSI (eLearning, Support and Innovation) is well positioned to assist academics and students with the development of such capacity. Although the unit are already involved in computer literacy and life-skills programs, additional resources are required to create a particular project that can meet the identified need for systematic digital literacy development. This digital literacy project will be designed to specifically to address the abovementioned issues and should have the flexibility to meet academic needs and build local capacity; It has three components

  1. Materials development: The development of a toolkit to facilitate digital experience. A series of professional development workshops that would introduce academics to patterns and techniques used to develop necessary skills
  2. Benchmarking: Ongoing progress with developing in class opportunities for student to practice their digital competencies within their specific discipline would be measured against a benchmark
  3. Community of Practice: The creation of a local network of expertise.

Marc Perensky’s mistake was to assume that because students were born within a digital era, that they are necessarily “digital natives”. The ability to effectively and critically navigate, evaluate and create information using a range of digital technologies is not inherent. To assist various stakeholders achieve digital literacies, it is essential that all members of the Wits community, academics, administration, library and other support services and students are offered opportunities to become sufficiently competent in the set of life skills that are necessary for full participation in our media-saturated, information-rich society.
With the number of students set to rise significantly in the next decade, this need for such digital literacies is magnified, as it will become imperative that Wits is able to adapt their traditional teaching methods and offer a mix of face-to-face and online learning possibilities and students will need to be technologically fluent to master this new mode.

 

Van Dijk, J., Hacker, K., 2003. The digital divide as a complex, dynamic phenomenon. The Information Society 19 (4), 315–326

Sharing Nicely

Creative Commons

That big annoying purple beast was right. Sharing is caring (I never thought I’d start a post by quoting Barney). Sharing nicely, especially when educational materials are concerned, is a natural impulse. But many education related organisations seem intent on curbing this generosity.

If you are part of a larger education related body (a publisher, university, research unit, school etc.), it might difficult to “share nicely”. While the mission of your organisation may be focused outwards with intentions to share research, educational expertise or learning content, these intentions could be contradicted by an “all rights reserved” approach to distributing your “intellectual property”.

Most practices and policies about sharing of work are premised on protecting their own interests. This is true. Organisations (and their employees) do need to be protected from being exploited. But that is also only half the story. Digital has enabled us to share our work at almost no cost. We have the opportunity to use the web as a vehicle to share freely, without paying for paper, ink and bookbinding. Others are able to use and add value to what we have produced.

If the intentions of your organisation, whether it relates to copyright, trademarks, patents and other claims for ‘ownership’ of intangible assets, is only intended to limit and protect, then its time to re-think this traditional approach. The narrow framing of an intellectual property policy (IPP) will create barriers for the outward mission and intentions of your institution.

Creative Commons licenses offer another route to protect you and your interests. This approach offers you and your organisation an alternative way of sharing. One sized copyright does not fit all. Traditionally, content creators have asserted their ownership of  teaching and reference materials using a copyright law. If they were lucky, these content creators could enter into an arrangement with a publisher to own the rights to his or her work. Those who benefited from this deal made mountains of money. But that was before the net changed the game.

Digital technology, when it was expensive, excluded many. But as the technologies of exclusion changed (the invention of the WWW), digital became cheaper. Exclusion from IP is far more difficult today and the cost of exclusion outweighs the value that can be derived from access to the resources. While not wanting to deprive the any person or organisation of potential revenue derived from IP, digital offers new routes to care and share. If such open behavior is to become institutionalized, then it is also necessary that their organisation’s IPP be unpacked.

An IPP  can be amended to allow for Creative Commons licenses. Employees can be granted the autonomy to value their own creative output and decide how they would like to determine the worth of their resources.  UCT, for example, have made this distinction within their IPP about what is valuable and what can be shared. In a presentation by Laura Czerniewicz, entitled Openness at the University of Cape Town, Laura showed how UCT had approached the issue of IPP and sharing resources. Their updated Intellectual Property policy now specifically addresses issues relating to the creation of shareable resources and the licensing processes to be followed.

Notable aspects of the updated policy are that UCT automatically assigns to the author(s) the copyright, unless UCT has assigned ownership to a third party in terms of a research contract. Course materials, with the provision that UCT retains a perpetual, royalty-free, nonexclusive licence to use, copy and adapt such materials within UCT for the purposes of teaching and or research, can be shared at the discretion of the creator of the materials.

So. Where do we start. Let’s start off by acknowledging that not every bit of your intellectual property needs to be kept locked up. Ask what materials can you start to give away. I’m not talking about sharing the left-overs. I’m talking about the real thing. But before hoarding it all on your hard drive, ask yourself, is this work totally unique with intrinsic value. Or will the value of these materials grow when it is shared?

As a consultant, I know that the value I offer does not lie in all my materials. I hope that some of my value to an organization is found in my expertise. These Creative Commons materials are evidence of my capabilities. In effect, they are an advert for my services. When it comes to sharing, I try to practice what I preach. Look at my blog. I license my “intellectual”, “creative” and “educational” output under a Creative Commons licence (under my posts, you’ll see a CC-BY licence). My SlideShare presentations are full of eye candy, not bullet points, and I make liberal use of Creative Commons images in an attempt to avoid #dbppt. These presentation materials are licensed in an open manner, so that others can build upon, re-arrange or improve  my work.

If you too believe in sharing, then your “intellectual”, “creative” and “educational” materials will need an appropriate licence. If you work for an organisation, then their ideas around ownership, trust, and attribution might need to be reconsidered before many colleagues will  open up and share their work to others.  For an organisation that wants to reach outwards, then Creative Commons offers a new way to reconsider and amend traditional copyright policy and closed practices. I will be working on an open educational resources policy soon.  Will “share nicely” under CC-By when it is ready.

 

My parents and ed-tech

Learning analytics treats students as numbers, invades privacy, and doesn’t elevate education. Originally published in IT Web 4 April 2003

An indispensable and comprehensive education technology from 1968

When I was about 6 months old, my well-meaning and sleep-deprived parents bought me an indispensable and comprehensive education technology:  the multivolume, all-inclusive reference source known as the Encyclopædia Britannica. The salesman convinced them that this “august repository of serious information”, organized alphabetically by topic and arranged over 26 volumes, had an impeccable pedigree, an excellent reputation and a history of trustworthiness. The pitch worked.  The “robust intellectual content” of the Encyclopædia Britannica was theirs and my cash- strapped parents spent the next two years paying off their first education technology purchase.

Today, education technologies offer the 21st century parent, similarly concerned about their children’s educational future, an almost infinite number of learning opportunities. From the World Wide Web to Wikipedia, from Moodle to MOOCs, this century has embraced the interwebs as the new “multivolume, all inclusive reference source”.  The rich collections of data associated with these “learning opportunities” are starting to interest educational entrepreneurs who see rich pickings in the process of analyzing data and packaging it in sets of marketable information. Much like Amazon is able to look through all my online purchases and suggest a new good read, or Facebook is able to suggest friends by determining the degrees of separation between me and the rest of the world, the computational process of discovering patterns in large educational data sets (data mining) is being touted by educational entrepreneurs as a solution for group work, career choices, retention rates and a higher quality, personalized experience.

Learning analytics is the current all-encompassing term used to describe this marriage between big data and educational records. Collecte data about students is being used to create models that will predict student progress and performance; and allow parents, students, teachers and administrators the ability to act on that information.

 Somewhere, probably in Silicon Valley, there’s a company or two coding an app that will collect all available data about students, including academic records, ANA test scores, financial circumstances, geographic location, attendance, assignments, progress, discipline, demographics and health. This company will soon be contacting your school or university IT administrator, claiming to offer counselling by aggregated data-mining.

Big data is hooking up with school reporting and Learning Analytics is their new love child. My guess is that the people coding this app do not have many educators on the design team. As Encyclopaedia Britannica was a sales-driven company, and not a scholarly one, data miners are looking at data as their source of profits. The absence of educators might make coders think that they are thinking outside of the box, but it is more likely that the absence of expertise or research will lead to an app that exacerbates current educational problems.  

My family’s Britannica sat on its own shelf in the lounge for years, and was used for the occasional school project, resolving points of debate and pressing flowers. Learning analytics may not be as benign. Learner analytics also comes at the expense of teacher-engagement.  Increasingly  stats- bound schools purchasing an app as described above will allow teachers to monitor what  is happening from their desk instead of taking the opportunity to engage in student learning and questions, coaching, facilitating and getting to know their learners.

 Education is more than the collection of patterns of data. Learning analytics may promise unlimited and useful information on students, but treating students as numbers invades privacy and doesn’t elevate education. It could lead to a watered-down, prescriptive education system with little human or humanising engagement.

Encyclopaedia  Britannica’s ubiquity was because the company was built by  “a culture of salesmen, not scholars”. With the likes of iPads, the Khan Academy and MOOCs, , I suspect that many parents, teachers, schools and faculties will soon also find themselves  under siege from similar Britannica- like salesmen, this time straight from Silicon Valley.  Their new pitch is an appealing one. They tell you that you can choose to use the data generated by learning analytics to improve the quality of your students’ prospects or you can remain disconnected and disadvantage your students prospects.

There’s no doubt that we need to make a serious effort to understand the processes of learning in our 21 century world. Learning analytics, however, cannot begin to reflect the complexity of these learning processes. Education cannot be reduced to a set of data patterns. Putting our faith in educational entrepreneurs’ ability to create another “august repository of serious information” is very much like my parents’ well intentioned choice to buy a Britannica.

It’s official – Sakai is the new LMS at Wits

Sakai Logo
News: Wits has formally adopted Sakai 

The wheels of Wits take a while to turn…but a decision has been made. Wits is going to move from KEWL  and WebCT to Sakai. A copy of the press release is below.


 

At the Senate meeting on the 10th of November, Prof Ballim, Deputy Vice-Chancellor, formally announced Wits’ decision to adopt Sakai as the new electronic learning environment at Wits. According to Tessa Murray, project manager in charge of this transition from Web CT to Sakai, the project is on track and the process of installing, configuring and customising Sakai is almost complete. Launching, implementing and supporting a replacement for WebCT by the end of 2012 will be a challenge for the next year, but eLSI (elearning, Support and Innovation) – the unit charged with replacing the current Learning Management System – is putting together road shows, presentations, workshops, training programmes and online support to ensure that Wits is ready for the new system.
The decision to adopt Sakai has involved extensive consultations, conversations and meetings. After a comprehensive study, undertaken in 2008, to consider the feasibility of both open source and proprietary alternatives to WebCT, the Senior Executive Team (SET) recommended that Wits adopt an open source approach platform. Following this approval, the University also took the decision not to renew the WebCT license after 2011 and began to explore its options regarding a campus-wide implementation of an open-source Learning Management System (LMS).

In early 2011, the Working Group concluded the evaluation and recommended that Wits adopt the Sakai collaboration and learning environment (CLE) as its eLearning platform. The recommendation was based on: the functional advantage of Sakai over other LMS solutions; the suitability of the Sakai technology in respect of established criteria; the initial and ongoing costs; the viability of the Sakai track record, user-base and pedagogy and technical support community; and the sustainability of the platform for Wits’ teaching, learning and research goals. In July 2011, the Wits SET approved the recommendation.

“Throughout 2012, Wits will run both WebCT and Sakai in parallel,” said Fatima Rahiman, lead learning designer at eLSI. Rahiman and other members of eLSI have been working in association with faculty nominated representatives in the Sakai Working Group to ensure that the new environment is ready for WebCT users to shift seamlessly over Sakai. In addition to ensuring parity with WebCT, faculty representatives and staff from other University units such as the library, Central Networking Services and SIMS have been drawn into discussion about the development of new functionalities – scheduled for 2013.

In the new year and over the first semester, staff from eLSI will be updating academics about the Sakai migration via Wits Clips articles, training sessions and meetings with individual faculty members and groups. If faculty have questions about Sakai or want to take a lead in the migration of their courses, Rahiman said that they should contact her or visit http://elearn.wits.ac.za to find out more.


 

Deadlines are tight. The WebCT license expires at the end of 2012. eLSI has got a year to familiarize academics with the new learning environment,  migrate existing courses accross from KEWL and WebCT and train academics on Sakai.

Open Access Week 2011


It’s the second year that Wits celebrates Open Access Week. Along with 2,000 individuals from more than 110 that have registered at openaccessweek.org, eLSI and the Library will be hosting two events.

24 October 2011 (Monday) 13.00-14.00
Wartenweiler Conference Room, 4th Floor
Theme: Open Access & Scholarly Communication

  • Prof. Yunus Ballim – “Wits and Open Scholarship”
  • Pierre Malan (Sabinet) – “The African Journal Archive”
  • Luci Abrahams (Wits LINK Centre) – “The OpenAir Project and South African Research”

26 October 2011 (Wednesday) 13.00-14.00
Wartenweiler Media Centre, 2nd Floor
Theme: Open Access Projects
Speakers:

  • Prof. Yunus Ballim – Welcome
  • Kerryn McKay – The African Commons Project
  • Shelley Nicholas – Neil Butcher & Associates
  • Barry Dwolatzky – Joburg Centre for Software Engineering

Bootcamp Lingo

As one of the last of the generation of white South Africans, who were conscripted to a wasted two years in the “”defense force”, the term “bootcamp” doesn’t site well with me. It conjures up an image of drilled troops, marching around while, a buzz cut officer barks orders to compliant recruits. Instead of creating the impression of an intensive in person course where a student can learn specific skills and get a job in a few months. I have the impression of to crude attempts to instill army discipline. with recruits only permitted to offer yes and no sir responses to any question.

While I don’t want to suggest that the current coding skills arrangements should be compared to apartheid armed forces. But I do want to enquire whether a “bootcamp”  is the best label to use when describing an attempt to address an anticipated coding skills shortfall? Might we avoid militaristic stereotypes (which don’t really sit very well with the average mild mannered computer geek). And stop think of this as a drilling event by army instructors, intnded to induct you into their “killing machine”?

Instead of framing these skills events as a bootcamp, might we find a metaphor that would help with the creation of more inclusive and equitable opportunities to help under represented groups to learn new skills. Find a gentler way to raise their awareness and address exclusionary stereotypes. To grow a coding community, who has been previously excluded, that seeks to erode and break the barriers that previously prevented them from making advanced use of their computers. To develop among attendees a growing in interest and confidence in their ability, without the need for drills, barked orders or military discipline.

Three steps to a Twitter +

Wouldn’t be useful if public posts on Google +were also published on Twitter?

It’s helpful when platforms can talk to each other. My tweets with links, for example, are automatically stored in my delicious account, thanks to packrati.us Google + looks like it has a future with other Google sites, but I’d like it to connect further – with Twitter.

To get the two connected, follow these three steps

  1. You are just a number to Google + but your unique number is special. Find it when you click on your Google + profile, then take a look in the URL bar and note that number.
  2. Go to plusfeed and create an unofficial atom feed.  Just paste your Google + account number after the above URL and it will generate an atom feed of your public posts.
  3. Signup for a service like Twitterfeed that enables you to send RSS feeds to your Twitter (or Facebook) account.

There – Google + is linked to Twitter. Your thought stream is now available as an information stream. Now all my public posts on Google + are also published on Twitter.

A wet & soggy account of ANT

Wits has decided that if they are going to prepare students for a 21st century world, then they will have to equip their students with connected digital devices that enable 21st century thinking and work. Accordingly, they have embarked on a number of projects to wirelessly connect the campus and improve the ratio of students who have access to computing devices. In understanding how this project is going to play out, I propose that I use ANT as a lens to understand the process, identify the actors that play a role in ICT diffusion at Wits and investigate the relationship between them.

Two weeks of dipping in and out of Latour’s Actor-Network Theory (ANT) has left my mind drenched with a new thought framework. Instead of looking for another article, I’ve decided to articulate what I have (and haven’t) grasped about material-semiotics. By straining my synapses through a textual sieve, I’m going to attempt to apply ANT to my area of study, and see what I’ve absorbed and what I need to clarify.

Why ANT
ANT is a reasonably established theory that has been used for understanding information systems. It avoids some of the common technology cliches; “ICT as an enabler” or “bridging the digital divide” . It supports thinking about the sociotechnical networks that incorporate people, computers, institutions, policies etc into ICT.

What is ANT
A repeated theme in the literature is that ANT refuses to be labeled as a theory or a methodology. ANT asks that the person to look at all “actants” (be they people or objects) and describe what they see. In this project at Wits, there are a range of different actants. Do I need to list all of them? Is it possible to list them all? No. I anticipate that what will emerge will be complicated, complex or chaotic. But the ANT lens says that we should resist the temptation to reduce what we see into natural, social, or discursive categories. Rather than reduce the various entities or see them as separate objects that can be manipulated, ANT asks the observer to note the actants and their relationship to each other.

How does ANT work?
The relationship between the heterogeneous actants interests is called a network. The formation of this network occurs by translation, not transmission. The stability of the network depends on the ability of the different actants to translate that is, re-interpret, re-present or appropriate, others’ interests to one’s own. There are four moments in translation; Problematisation, Intressement, Enrolment, Mobilisation of allies. In order to bring clarity – the focus on the process of translation is usually taken from the point of view of a single actor

What will the ANT framework accomplish?
Who shapes, enables and constrains change in an organisation? People or technology? The debate as to has agency swings between technology and society. ANT would argue that the relationship between technology and humans are interwoven. Although technology is changing rapidly, technology does not drive the development of an organizations’s values. But neither can an organization behaviors be entirely explained by social interactions and constructs. Rather, ANT argues that human and non human actors have agency and create a network that influences how things get done. ANT ask that we acknowledge the reciprocal and dynamic interaction between technology and humans.
Disclaimer
This is by no means intended as accurate or authoritative account of ANT. It’s me squeezing my brain against words (much like a sponge against the palm of my hand), waiting to see if anything useful emerges. Please feel free to comment. Hopefully my mind will feel less soggy soon.

Digital Slates

Digital slates
Digital slates
So, you want to move from OHP transparencies, where you portably project the process of working through a problem to a class on a transparency, to a more modern device that should allow you to do the same…and more.

Projecting and recording the process of obtaining a solution on a data projector should be simple, portable and cost effective. Yes? Sadly no. This is technology. Things are not always easy to master or easy on the back pocket.

The OHP allows the process to be demonstrated in small or big steps in front of the class. A PowerPoint presentation is great for presenting a prepared show, but it does not really allow the teacher to modify the presentation on the fly and decide what size steps they will take as he/she presents the sums up in front of the classroom. So what other options are there.

Option 1 – Interactive Whiteboard
Go ahead, blow your budget and install a interactive whiteboard, and give your class a large monitor on which you can write, show and record. But whiteboards are costly, they re-enforce student passivity and carrying a white board around to your different lecture venue is fairly tricky.

Option 2 – A tablet computer
Be trendy and purchase a tablet computer (preferably an iPad 2) and a stylus and wirelessly connect with the data projector. Then demonstrate your working process on screen and walk around the class and show solutions to specific problems that students are facing. But tablets are expensive, the stylus may not be as precise (and using your finger to write does not work). Hooking up to the data projector wirelessly is not as straightforward as it sounds.

Option 3 – Plug in your pen and pad
Before you ditch those transparencies, scan them and convert them to a PDF. Now project the scanned transparencies on the data projector, and then write on the transparencies with a digital drawing device. Want to show and image or video. Then hyperlink to the resource. Digital drawing devices are cheap, but they do require new skills and an extra layer of technology to be plugged into the laptop

Option 4 – Get a Smartpen
Or get out some paper and a special pen and press record. The pen has a small camera installed and your handwriting and audio is recorded and then can be downloaded to a PC. The working process can be projected on the data projector – but if you want the process to be visible in real time, you need to forgo the pens recording ability.

None of the solutions are perfect, they never are. Option 3 is the cheapest, option 4, the most portable and option 2, once you’ve installed the bits, may be the simplest.