My first week in Jozi

Welcome to Wits
With the sound of afternoon traffic, an amplified African guitar and the evening sun inviting me to knock off from work, I thought I’d take a breath and reflect on the memorable, exciting and sad moments since being appointed to the eLearning, Support and Innovation Unit at Wits University on June 1.

With the 2010 Soccer World Cup round the corner, the excitement is palpable. Car flags wave, buildings are plastered with adverts, lampposts hold banners and soccer T shirts loudly proclaim their wearers loyalty to various national teams. Conversations around me are peppered with who has tickets for what, whether Bennie was really fat and where will you be watching the games from.

I’ve also been wonderfully welcomed, orientated, introduced, processed etc by people within the University and up in the city. Opportunities to connect with people and their work are welcomed occasions and I relish fresh collaboration prospects that may (to use a terrible phrase) “add value” to the universities work. Already there are three possible initiatives that I might be involved in:
• QR codes on University signage
• E Learning and Digital literacy resources for the library
• The curricular possibilities of ‘One Computing Device Per Student’

The memorable and stimulating moments have to share some space with a poignant loss of intimacy between Jean, Anna, Cara and myself. Despite the alleged glamour of a bachelor life in Jozi, sometimes I find myself choked up with longing as l miss my daughters and partner.

It is, however, with gratitude that I pack up for the week. My appreciation for friends that have made me feel welcome, colleagues that have invited me to participate with them on their projects and Wits University for employing me to learn work and get paid in an exciting and dynamic field is heartfelt. I’m looking forward to Monday.

An inspiring knight in Cape Town

Sir John Daniel -Photographed from my crummy web camera

Schoolnet and the Commonwealth of Learning invited me (and a variety of highups in Education)  to a day long seminar in Cape Town around the topic of  ICT integration and teacher training. The key note speaker was the inspiring knight, Sir John Daniel. Not only did he take 25 years to complete a part-time Master’s degree in Educational Technology at Concordia University, but he’s also the president and CEO of the Commonwealth of Learning since 2004 after previous appointments as assistant director-general of UNESCO and vice-chancellor of the UK Open University and that’s only a summary of the last 10 years of his career.

At the seminar, Sir John chatted about the Second United Nations Millennium Development Goal – Universal Primary Education – and argued that these goals were well on their way to being achieved. As of 2008, over 570 million children were now able to complete a full course of primary schooling and only 50 million children were not primary schooled. The success of the campaign however, has created a new problem, that of Universal Secondary Education. The scale of the challenge is vast. 400 million children aged 12-17 are not in secondary school and 10 million more teachers are required by 2015 if this problem is to be addressed.

Sir John then went ahead to explore some interesting ideas to train more teachers and effectively retrain and motivate those in the profession. He suggested that countries should be recruiting people and sending them into the classroom within minimal training. Then, while they are teaching, they should receive in-service training that is in the schools and that addresses classroom realities. In order for this to happen, institutions will have to use open & distance learning and ICT.

His latest book – Mega-Schools, Technology and Teachers: Achieving Education for All – he explores the implications of using ICT for open and distance learning. The publicity blurb says that the book covers:

  • the creation and expansion of Mega-Schools, which combine distance learning and community support and have a proven track record of increasing access at scale
  • how to prepare the 10 million new teachers that are required to achieve Education for All by 2015 by focusing on classroom-based in-service training.
  • strategies for using technology to scale up distance education cost-effectively.
  • the creation of a 21st century educational ecosystem that integrates open schooling and teacher education with communities and their school systems.
  • successful examples of open schools and teacher education programmes operating at scale around the world.

Sir John is an amazing person. He has a global vision for education and an appreciation of how educational technology can provide secondary education to tens of millions of young people around the world. If the book is as good as his engaging presentation, then it’s certainly another must read for my bookshelf.

Passing nodes on a network

What would make a normally sane person leave their secure and predictable routine, fly to another city (or country) and voluntary sit for days in meeting after meeting? A good meal, a legitimate excuse to duck family responsibility or the possibility that you might meet a person that could revolutionise your life.  For me, probably none of the above. What takes me away from home is the opportunity to meet a bunch of similarly minded delegates, to talk, share ideas and practice. Strangers at conference are less strange because they share the same interests as you do. It’s an optical delusion though. This  atmosphere of ambient intimacy that has been created around this temporary community will probably vanish, until we meet again at another conference. It does not have to be this way though. Conference organisers, caught in the rush of the urgent, sometimes neglect to include in the programme networking opportunities.  Below are 12 points to consider when organising a conference that would enhance nodes (like me) networking capacity.

Before the conference
1. You have a hidden audience.
Remember to include people that could not physically attend the event. Think about ways in which they could participate
2. Like and Retweet
Create a Facebook and/or Twitter account for the conference and ensure that a Facebook “like” button or a Twitter “retweet” button appears on your conference web page.
3. Let’s play tag
Select a conference tag and ask that when speakers post resources that pertain to their presentation on their blog, Twitter, Delicious, YouTube, Facebook that they also use this tag.
4. TweetUp
Number the tables and suggest that delegates arrange a Tweetup – put real faces to avatars – at a selected table number at a certain time
5. Network Weaving
Supply delegates with speakers Twitter, LinkedIn and Facebook profiles

During the conference
6. Expand the four walls of your conference venue
Take and upload photos to a conference page, live blog the proceedings, record or stream the keynote presentation
7. Get them talking
Ensure that the key note speaker’s presentation has a tea break scheduled right after so that the delegates can discuss what was said.
8. Ride the backchannel
Delegates are passing notes electronically, probably using the conference tag as a hashtag (if they are on Twwitter). Project the backchannel onto a screen during the conference
9. Hotspots Help
Ensure that WiFi is available and that delegates can login without too many hurdles

After the conference
10. Delegates Directory
Send an email to all delegates thanking them for attending and informing them of a conference attendees directory
11. Sharing is caring
If speakers presentations were not available on the web before the conference, ensure that they are available after the conference
12. Continue the conversation
A conference Facebook account or Twitter account need to fade into oblivion immediately after the conference. Use these tools to elicit thoughts, ideas etc from speakers and delegates.

Connecting the dots

I’ll come to listen to your parade of movers and shakers, spend the night comfortably cosseted in clean linen. Thanks for the food, flight and great speakers. You’re obviously serious and I must admit, I’m flattered that you want me to come to your do. Although it makes me sound a bit ungrateful (and I’m not), let me tell you how you could be getting better bang for your conference buck.

If you want to ensure that your messages are heard by people that matter – then look for people that use a range of processes for communicating online. They’re connecting (sometimes very loosley) to like minded people interested in formulating relationships with other likeminded people with the express purpose of communicating and developing knowledge. Try engaging these individuals with online identities. They’re mavens trying to join the dots together. Your conference is an opportunity to broaden the conversation and you’ll find that if you connect, they aren’t scared of sharing their thoughts.

So once the thank-you’s have been said, the business cards exchanged, Linkedin Profiles updated, and all other network schmuckwork dissipates at the end of the conference, remember oh conference organiser, that “knowledge – and therefore the learning of knowledge – is distributive, and not located in any given place.” As Downes explains, knowledge consists of the network of connections formed from experience and interactions with a knowing community. So if you are really looking to connect your impressive programme to key people …. then organising a get together of key people in a big city and spend thousands of rands flying in delegates to a hotel stay sandwiched with a seminar filling is only the start of the process. Sorry, you thought the conference was over.

Potholes ahead – caution advised

Computer literacy training, employing experts and certification are three potholes on the info-bahn that might damage your  institutions attempts to effectively use ICT (information and communications technology).

Goveia and Soule’s article argues that if we are to foster ongoing and sustainable use of learning technologies in schools, there are three common “potholes” that we need to watch out for, as these indentions could keep teachers at an operational level in their journey along the info-bahn.

  • Pothole 1 – We need training in ICT .
    Our focus needs to be on our own teaching processes, and enquire if / how the available technology can enable / enhance our own practices. Educators need to understand what kind of teaching approach that they want and/or how they might use the technology to foster this kind of teaching and learning activities.
  • Pothole 2 – We need an expert
    Good and experienced educators should be able to recognize tools that will contribute positively to their professional and classroom practice. Apply class use cases, find YouTube  examples and let the expert’s do the modelling. Watching them apply their knowledge is probably more satisfying than listening to an expert telling a passive audience about the potential of a tool or how they might apply the technology in a set of circumstances. If an expert is required, then pre-warn them with scenarios, which they could address. Let the “expert” demonstrate appropriate uses of technology. Better still is to give educators themselves an opportunity to experiment and design teaching and learning activities for challenges they are facing.
  • Pothole 3 – We need a certificate
    Becoming capable with new technologies and applying them to your class is a  lifelong endeavor. Certification verifies that a particular skill or skill set was obtained at a particular time. It does not illustrate how the skill was used to promote learning. Neither does it prepare you for the next update or replacement tech. If you want to identify your competency to others, then I think that an educator’s portfolio is a better demonstration of their experiences in using technology than examining a collection certificates.

Training will not launch educators onto the road towards ICT confidence and competency. An expert might know about the finer points of computing, and might inspire staff to use ICT, but a guru’s knowledge in IT is most valuable when it is applied.  Experience is best demonstrated, and certification does not indicate ongoing competency.

Training, experts and certificates, the three aforementioned “potholes”, may be services within your professional development programme. But in the long term, these potholes lead towards dependency and will not  encourage agency or a DIY approach amongst teachers and let them take ownership of their own ICT development. If we are going to encourage teachers to adopt, appropriate and innovate with ICT, we need to think about ways that teachers can take themselves beyond entry-level ICT use, and sustain their own educational ICT development.

Further Reading

TeachMeet

TeachMeet
TeachMeet is an informal gathering of those curious about teaching and technology. Anyone can share great ideas they’ve trialled in their classrooms, ask important questions or simply sign up to take part in learning conversations. Both Primary and Secondary teachers are welcome to take part in an informal and fun meeting. You can come along to chat, meet new people, or give a seven minute talk, a two minute nano presentation or lead a conversation.

Tim and Moby Explain

Teachmeet is a meeting of uh well Teachers. I’ll leave it to  Tim and Moby to explain further technical details. I’d like to know if you are interested in joining me make it happen. Date, Time Venue, Publicity etc?

Passing notes on the IWB back channel

As an Interactive White Board (IWB) newbie and the  mercenary Ed Tech man, I thought it a good idea to master the newly installed giant touch screens to prove my learning tech credentials.

It’s quite common to call IWB’s Smartboards, but that’s like calling a vacuum cleaner a Hoover or a spreadsheet program Excel.  You are advertising  the brand name for free.

George @veletsianos kindly brought me up to speed with his IWB lecture. Mining for independent research on IWB reveals little. General consensus amongst the gurus is that this technology give teachers a clever (and expensive) surface with a range of presentation options. Improvement in results (especially in maths) have been reported, but those improvements seem only temporary. The other angle from the research was that IWBs doesn’t do that much for developing a constructivist learning environment. Thus far – not a pretty picture.

Anecdotal accounts from teachers tell a different story from the  research and I found examples of practice (especially at primary school level) extolling the virtues of the technology. It’s clear that teachers that are comfortable with IWBs are enjoying the opportunity to interact with the data and resources in front of the class.

Sadly, all my pre-research came to naught, as I discovered that while the screen and projector had been installed, the IWB had not been calibrated and the software not delivered. So instead of using any of the boards to instruct (we have a choice), I put the BACK into back channel, turned the class round with their rear ends facing the IWB, took up @injenuity ‘s challenge, let go of my PowerPoint and handed out my notes.

Students were introduced to the back channel concept and encouraged to open their laptops, connect with their phones and use their Twitter accounts, the #ukznav hashtag and participate in “note passing” during the lesson.

Things that I learned

I saw a few whispers but no scribbled notes passed around during the class. Perhaps my students are too kind for the salacious gossip associated with notes. Or maybe they did not see the need. A back channel usually requires a bigger class than I had. It’s hard to pass notes electronically when the teacher looms large.  A back channel is suitable when there’s a sea of faces and a wealth of ICT devices.

When using the back channel it’s useful to have an application (such as Todaysmeet) that aggregates your classes Tweets in realtime. I entered our #ukznav hashtag in Twitter’s search and had to ask Pravesh to refresh the page.

It also requires practice to present content and respond to short messages on the back channel. I found it difficult to work through my material and reply coherently to the points projected on the IWB. Doing this in front of a large class that were back channeling properly could be quite scary.

It’s certainly an experiment that I’d like to repeat. With  a choice of projection options I might land up using the data projector and the IWB. I might even mix channels and embed a coupe of Tweets into the PPT presentation. As always, I’d be interested to hear of what you thought / think of these ideas.   Comments are yours.

Recipe for a connected educator

Give your teacher a computer, preferably a cheap one, install  software and other learning technologies and then when they complete your introductory course (with gold embossed certificate), reward their efforts with a voucher for a months free Internet connection. Simple – we’ve got a connected educator.

Or maybe not. I’ve set up a straw man proposal, and I’m kicking Aunt Sally around to make my point. Digitally effective teaching and learning is often hampered by access and resources. Computers break, software can be expensive, internet access (here in South Africa) is expensive and, most importantly, training for teachers that share the same interests, have the same skill levels or are interested in the same outcomes is seen as a “once off event”, not an ongoing process.

Don’t frame these problems as a Digital divide – the hassles we’ve mentioned are not a permanent. They are perceptual, temporary  or environmental. I call these problems digital dongas.  A technological ditch, caused by erosion of opportunities, experiences, skills, and knowledge. With attention, time and conversations with affected educational communities, this scarring can be stopped or maybe even repaired.

So if you are interested in getting teachers connected, stop the reductionalism. Solving issues of technological access will not create a connected teacher. The conversation needs to move forward to focus on the participation skills required for teachers to benefit from the technology. Find opportunities for teachers to contribute and to develop the their competencies and social skills needed for involvement. Recognise that each institution has a set of dongas and then begin working in collaboration with with schools and the teachers to bridge or start repairing the gaps. Remember though, bridging digital dongas is a process, not an event. A one-time teacher training workshop does not count as  effective professional development. Start thinking more about the teachers on-going, relevant professional development, and how you can support that process.

mLearning

Phillipa and Ryan are a little puzzled

Frustrated students are starting to doubt the future of progress. For the past two weeks I’ve inflicted a Mobile code hunt on their them, in attempt to demonstrate that mobile phones have potential outside the walls of the classroom.  They’ve sat, squinted and swore for an hour trying to figure out how to download a QR code reader to their Mobile phones so that they could find the answers on a QR code.  This morning, of the 20 students, only one managed to download the reader (the other students phone models did not support the code or they had no air time). While it was clear that many students were adept at managing their phones and could work around a small screen, the problem of a common platform made me doubt the possibilities that mLearning holds for whole class learning. The range of different phone models makes it extremely difficult to supply instructions on how to configure the phone.

mLearning certainly holds enormous pedegogic and practical potential.  But whether the phone has the ability to act as “a classroom in your pocket” will depend on the degree of uniformity amongst phones. The wide variety of phones amongst students meant that nobody was able to assist each other, as each had a different phone. Background of the mobile phone owner will also play a part in their ability to master the tool. It was interesting to note that students that had some business or other experience beyond the classroom were able to make better use of their phone.

Ah well, back to the drawing board, more prototypes, more thought is required.