I’ve just tasted this cocktail of confusion. I spent an hour introducing the LAN to a student who’se managed to avoid browser wars, Hotmail, e-commerce, Google thedotcombomb, Youtube, Facebook etc. The jargon and the process was unfamiliar and obscure. The purpose of the login exercise did not communicate security. It spoke of trickery and confusion, things that you’d expect a usability expert to have simplified by now.
Firstly, you have to swipe your card at the help desk (located 10 minutes away from this lan). Secondly, you have to enter your user number and then your password. Thirdly, after entering your password, you are prompted to add a new one, and then to repeat this new one, and if you don’t think of a “secure” password, you’ll be asked to repeat step 3 again. With login done, the fourth step is to attempt to access your e-mail. And so you repeat the process of usernames and passwords. And then if you are to make use of any social media – the process has to be repeated again.
Why, when the LAN is used primarily by students that don’t have a computer at home, does it have to be so darn difficult to logon to a network? When swiping the card, the “help” desk could use a branching test to easily establish whether the user was a newbie and give the struggling student a small tutorial in login procedures. A single hand out with the space for a user to fill in their username and password might avoid countless confused students. Or how about an ambient gaming overlay that will nudge users forwards. At least create a screen saver that offers a login tutorial might assist the student scaffold their thoughts.
The banking industry have managed to simplify the login procedure to access money from an ATM. OpenID is making it safe, faster and easier to log in to web sites. Kodak (and other film companies) have managed to get photographers to use their terminals to print out photos, but network security technicians (or whoever is responsible for the LAN login process) have re-enforced a late adopters inferiority complex and excluded them from participating all because of network security.
There must be ways that can make connecting to the net work a little less work?